Understanding Why People Turn to Conspiracy Theories During Crises

Last Updated Feb 28, 2025

During crises, people often turn to conspiracy theories as a way to make sense of chaos and regain a sense of control in uncertain situations. The human brain seeks coherent explanations to reduce anxiety, and conspiracy theories provide simple answers to complex problems. This need for understanding and security drives individuals to adopt alternative narratives that align with their fears or distrust of authorities.

The Psychological Roots of Conspiracy Theories

Conspiracy theories often emerge during crises due to the human brain's need for cognitive closure and a sense of control in uncertain situations. You seek patterns and explanations that reduce anxiety, leading to the psychological roots of these theories in confirmation bias, mistrust, and the desire for social belonging. These mental mechanisms provide a misguided but comforting narrative that explains complex events through simple, intentional actions by powerful groups.

Social Uncertainty and the Rise of Conspiratorial Thinking

During crises, social uncertainty drives individuals to seek explanations that restore a sense of control, leading to the rise of conspiratorial thinking as a coping mechanism. You may find that conspiracy theories offer simplified narratives that reduce ambiguity and align with group identities, reinforcing in-group cohesion. This psychological need to resolve uncertainty fuels the spread of misinformation and challenges rational decision-making in social contexts.

Altruism in Crisis: Helping Others Through Shared Narratives

During crises, altruism drives people to share and believe in conspiracy theories as a way to protect and help their community by creating shared narratives that explain chaotic events. You seek these stories to feel connected and to provide support, reinforcing collective identity and fostering cooperation. Such shared beliefs often serve as tools for collective problem-solving and emotional reassurance amid uncertainty.

The Role of Community and Belonging in Conspiracy Beliefs

People often turn to conspiracy theories during crises to fulfill their innate need for community and belonging, as these beliefs provide a shared narrative that fosters social cohesion among like-minded individuals. The collective endorsement of conspiracy theories creates a sense of identity and support, reducing feelings of isolation and uncertainty. This social bonding mechanism enhances group solidarity, making conspiracy theories a refuge for those seeking connection in times of stress.

How Fear and Anxiety Fuel Conspiracy Theories

Fear and anxiety heighten during crises, driving individuals to seek explanations that restore a sense of control and certainty, making conspiracy theories appealing. These emotional states activate cognitive biases, such as pattern recognition and agency detection, which reinforce belief in conspiratorial narratives. The need to alleviate uncertainty motivates people to adopt these theories as coping mechanisms, even in the absence of evidence.

Cognitive Biases and Their Influence on Crisis Narratives

Cognitive biases such as confirmation bias and proportionality bias heavily influence why people gravitate toward conspiracy theories during crises, as these biases drive individuals to seek patterns and assign deliberate causes to complex events for comfort and understanding. The need for cognitive closure intensifies in uncertain situations, making simplified crisis narratives more appealing despite a lack of evidence. These biases distort information processing, reinforcing altruistic motives to protect loved ones by adhering to seemingly explanatory but inaccurate theories.

Polarization and Social Identity: Us vs. Them

During crises, polarization intensifies as people seek belonging within social groups, often adopting conspiracy theories to reinforce an "us vs. them" mentality. This social identity dynamic strengthens in-group cohesion by vilifying outsiders, providing a sense of security and purpose. Your alignment with these narratives satisfies a deep psychological need to protect your group from perceived threats.

The Impact of Social Media on Conspiracy Spread

Social media platforms amplify conspiracy theories by rapidly disseminating unverified information through algorithms that prioritize engagement over accuracy. This widespread circulation distorts your perception of reality during crises, fostering distrust and fear. The echo chambers created by social media reinforce false beliefs, making it harder for accurate information to penetrate.

Building Trust: Counteracting Misinformation During Crises

During crises, people often turn to conspiracy theories as a means to find explanations amid uncertainty, reflecting a deep need for trust and clarity. Building trust requires transparent communication, consistent facts, and empathetic engagement to counteract misinformation effectively. Your role in fostering open dialogue and sharing verified information strengthens communal resilience against the spread of false narratives.

Fostering Critical Thinking and Altruism for Resilience

People often follow conspiracy theories during crises because they seek clear explanations to reduce uncertainty and fear. Fostering critical thinking equips you with analytical tools to question misleading information and recognize cognitive biases. Encouraging altruism builds community trust and resilience, creating a supportive environment where truth and cooperation prevail over misinformation.

Important Terms

Epistemic Uncertainty Motive

During crises, the Epistemic Uncertainty Motive drives individuals to seek clear explanations to reduce the discomfort caused by ambiguous or incomplete information, making conspiracy theories appealing as they provide seemingly coherent narratives. This motive fulfills the psychological need for cognitive closure, helping people manage anxiety by imposing order on chaotic events through simplified causal attributions.

Collective Paranoia

Collective paranoia during crises emerges as individuals seek meaning and control amidst chaos, driving them to embrace conspiracy theories that offer simplistic explanations for complex events. This shared distrust fuels group cohesion while amplifying fear and suspicion, often undermining altruistic behaviors essential for effective crisis response.

Information Void Anxiety

During crises, people often experience Information Void Anxiety, a psychological discomfort caused by the lack of clear or reliable information, which drives them to seek explanations through conspiracy theories. This need for certainty activates altruistic intentions, as individuals believe sharing alternative narratives helps protect their community from hidden threats.

Sensemaking Under Duress

During crises, individuals often turn to conspiracy theories as a coping mechanism to restore a sense of control and understanding when faced with uncertainty and fear. This sensemaking under duress helps alleviate anxiety by providing simplified explanations and clear narratives that address complex events.

Existential Threat Perception

Existential threat perception heightens anxiety and uncertainty, driving individuals to adopt conspiracy theories as coping mechanisms that provide simplified explanations and a sense of control. This psychological response to perceived threats reinforces communal bonds through shared beliefs, even when such theories lack empirical support.

Social Validation Loop

During crises, individuals often follow conspiracy theories due to the Social Validation Loop, where repeated exposure and group reinforcement create a feedback cycle that solidifies belief. This loop leverages social conformity and confirmation bias, leading people to seek validation from like-minded communities, which amplifies the perceived credibility of conspiratorial narratives.

Crisis-Induced Tribalism

Crisis-induced tribalism drives individuals to seek belonging and identity within in-groups, fostering allegiance to conspiracy theories that reinforce group cohesion and distrust of outsiders. This social dynamic heightens collective anxiety, making people more susceptible to simplistic, emotionally charged explanations that validate their group's perspective during uncertain times.

Cognitive Closure Urgency

Cognitive closure urgency drives individuals to quickly resolve uncertainty during crises, making conspiracy theories appealing as they offer clear, simplified explanations. This urgent need for certainty overrides critical thinking, leading people to prioritize immediate answers over evidence-based information.

Meaning-Making Vacuum

During crises, individuals often experience a Meaning-Making Vacuum where uncertainty and anxiety create a psychological need for clear explanations, driving them toward conspiracy theories that offer simplistic, coherent narratives. This search for meaning satisfies a deep altruistic desire to protect others by making sense of chaotic events and finding perceived truth amid widespread misinformation.

Scapegoating Reflex

The scapegoating reflex triggers individuals to blame specific groups or figures during crises, providing a psychological mechanism to alleviate uncertainty and fear. This reflex often drives the adoption of conspiracy theories as people seek clear targets for collective anxiety and perceived threats, reinforcing social cohesion through shared blame.



About the author.

Disclaimer.
The information provided in this document is for general informational purposes only and is not guaranteed to be complete. While we strive to ensure the accuracy of the content, we cannot guarantee that the details mentioned are up-to-date or applicable to all scenarios. Topics about why people follow conspiracy theories during crises are subject to change from time to time.

Comments

No comment yet